Mexican Gothic by Sylvia Moreno-Garcia

 

Moreno-Garcia's master's thesis was on women
and eugenics in Lovecraft's works

As I was reading Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia, the one thought that kept running through my mind was, "My, God! This woman writes beautifully!" She crafts her sentences with such limpid clarity that the book is a pleasure to read on that level alone. That's helpful because the story develops very slowly for fully two thirds of the novel's length, carefully putting each element in place, before the full horror is finally revealed. Review Reviewers often mention Rebecca and Wuthering Heights when reaching for comparisons to Mexican Gothic, and they could also invoke My Cousin Rachel for the plot device that motivates our heroine Noemí Taboada to visit High Place. The real progenitors of this novel aren't so much gothic romances, though, as they are gothic horrors like Bram Stoker's Dracula and Matthew Lewis's The Monk, as well as weird tales like Charlotte Perkins Gilman's The Yellow Wallpaper and H.P. Lovecraft's The Colour Out of Space. For the record, Moreno-Garcia cites the stories of Horacio Quiroga and the horror films of Carlos Enrique Taboada as influences, though I confess to being unfamiliar with them. The evil patriarch of High Place is Howard Doyle, the name being a bit of a tribute to Howard Philips Lovecraft and Conan Doyle. Howard Doyle's "enormous jawline," of course, evokes Lovecraft's unusual appearance. Discredited theories of eugenics play an important role in this novel (a reference to Lovecraft's racist beliefs), as do the legacies of colonialism, racism, and misogyny in Mexico. But the real villain of this piece is Virgil, a Dracula-like seducer if there ever was one. The mounting disquiet that Virgil invokes draws you into the narrative as Noemí finds her mind gradually slipping. The eventual denouement does not disappoint. With suddenly escalating tension, disgusting rituals, and the revelation of a loathsome abomination in the catacombs below, this is gothic horror at its finest.